red
Slander Pinot Noir
Orin Swift Cellars
Vintage & Drinking Window
🍷
Drinking Window
Drink now through 2026. Currently at peak maturity. The massive 15.2 percent ABV and modest acidity suggest it will not improve with further cellar aging; the fruit will fade.
Perfect time to enjoy!
Vintage Notes
The 2018 California growing season was widely celebrated as a return to calm after the devastating, fire-ravaged 2017 vintage. A cooler-than-average spring with steady, slow development was followed by a temperate, long summer devoid of extreme heat spikes. This extended hang time allowed for generous yields and physiological ripeness without the rushed, panic-picking of hotter years. However, in the hands of a producer seeking maximum extraction, the long season was utilized to push brix levels to the extreme. Compared to the more linear and tightly wound 2019s, the 2018s possess an inherent plushness. Within the Orin Swift portfolio, this is a middle-of-the-pack vintage, consistent and cleanly made, but lacking the nervous energy or cut that might have made it truly memorable. It is a drink-now vintage currently in its peak tertiary phase and will not reward further cellaring.
AI Confidence: 92%
$45.00 - $60.00 USD
91/100Outstanding
Sophie's Take
Listen to Sophie talk about Slander Pinot Noir
0:000:00
Grape Varieties
100% Pinot Noir
Style: Evaluating this wine demands checking stylistic prejudices at the door and adhering strictly to the BLIC framework (Balance, Length, Intensity, Complexity). Slander 2018 delivers formidable Intensity, overwhelming the palate's center with highly concentrated red fruits and sweet vanilla tones. However, its Balance is fiercely contested; the low-to-medium acidity and silky, medium-minus tannins struggle to integrate with and contain the colossal 15.2 percent alcohol, resulting in a somewhat hot, heavy-set profile rather than internal harmony. Complexity is moderate at best; it relies on a stark contrast between overt primary fruit and heavy oak rather than nuanced, layered integration. The Length is regrettably medium; it drops off swiftly into a warm, woody finish once the initial rush of fruit subsides. A short finish on a complex wine is a real flaw worth naming, and here the alcohol outlasts the fruit. Regarding typicity, Slander 2018 deviates wildly from classical Pinot Noir expectations. It represents the quintessential Napa-winemaker interpretation of the grape: broad, opaque, and entirely devoid of the variety's inherent fragility. This massive deviation from classicism is its defining weakness for traditionalists, yet paradoxically, it remains perfectly typical for Orin Swift's loyal fan base, serving as a reliable commercial strength. Trade-off: This wine is definitively not for traditionalists, Burgundy lovers, or anyone seeking the ethereal, haunting precision that Pinot Noir is famous for. If you buy Slander, you trade site-specific transparency, tension, and linearity for sheer volume, extraction, and blunt impact. For a buyer with $50 to spend who genuinely wants structural energy, lift, and regional articulation in their California Pinot Noir, a peer wine at a similar price point, such as Sandhi Sta. Rita Hills or Au Bon Climat Knox Alexander, will serve them far better, offering superior finesse without the burden of excessive alcohol.
Alcohol: 15.2%
Tasting Notes
Flavors of pomegranate and orange peel offer a fleeting burst of bright citrus rind
Medium length, dropping off quickly to leave traces of soft oak tannin and toasted brioche
Nose of ripe cranberry, raspberry tart, and rhubarb pie with a volatile alcohol lift
Palate entry shows a silky tannin texture wrapped around intense bing cherry galette
Aromas of dried rose petals offer a brief, classic varietal floral note
Mid-palate expands with Madagascar vanilla, heavily marked by 42 percent new French oak
Professional Ratings
Wine Spectator: 91/100
Robert Parker: 91/100
Serving Recommendations
Temperature: 15-18 C (60-64 F). Serving slightly chilled is essential to suppress the palpable heat of the 15.2 percent alcohol, which otherwise overwhelms the palate at room temperature.
Decanting: 30 to 60 minutes. At 30 minutes, the volatile high-toned alcohol begins to integrate. At 60 minutes, the oak-derived baking spices and vanilla merge with the extracted fruit.
Food Pairing:
Roasted duck breast with cherry reduction
Hoisin-glazed barbecue pork ribs
Grilled portobello mushrooms with balsamic glaze
Braised pork belly with soy and star anise
Avoid: Delicate poached sole (the 15.2 percent ABV and extracted fruit will obliterate the fish)
Surprise: Spicy tuna rolls (the fruit weight and subtle sweetness handle chili heat well)
Surprise: Point Reyes blue cheese (the bold extraction stands up to the pungent mold)
Winemaking & Vineyard
Production Notes:
Orin Swift Cellars was founded by Dave Phinney in 1998, famously naming the brand after his father's middle name and his mother's maiden name. Phinney is arguably California's most successful 'brand maker,' known for rich, extracted, unctuous blends and highly arresting packaging. The legend of Slander begins with a decade of frustration. Phinney, a master of robust Zinfandel and Cabernet blends, struggled immensely with the finicky nature of Pinot Noir. After years of toiled attempts to make a Pinot worth bottling, he finally found his recipe in 2015 by abandoning conventional restraint and harvesting the fruit at an ultra-ripe 25 brix before it verged into pure strawberry jam territory. In a nod to the humble barrel samples of his early days, the unforgettable moment of Slander's design came when Phinney simply wrapped a piece of grey duct tape around the bottle and scrawled the name on it with a marker. However, behind the indie-garage aesthetic lies immense corporate reality. In 2016, E. & J. Gallo purchased Orin Swift for an undisclosed sum, acquiring the brands, inventory, and tasting room. Phinney remains the winemaker and creative director, but Slander 2018 was produced entirely under Gallo's ownership. The brand's controversial transformation from boutique visionary to corporate juggernaut worries purists who view the wines as engineered crowd-pleasers rather than agricultural expressions. The 2018 vintage ranks as a middle-of-the-pack release for this specific label. It lacks the tight, coiled energy of the 2019s, relying instead on the generous, calm weather of the 2018 season to achieve maximum extraction. In the peer hierarchy of California Pinot Noir, it sits squarely in the value-luxury commercial tier alongside brands like Meiomi and Belle Glos, built for impact, not for aging. The market sees Slander as highly accessible; it is readily available and not a collectible investment vehicle. Its price trajectory remains stable around the $50 mark, driven by brand loyalty rather than secondary market demand. Direct competitors include Belle Glos Clark & Telephone, which offers a similarly dark, sweet-fruited profile, and Kosta Browne, which achieves this massive style with considerably more mid-palate complexity. While Slander delivers more unabashed hedonism than its traditional peers, it fundamentally lacks the nuance of the great Sonoma Coast producers. Addressing Asimov's central question: does it reward attention, or is it competent and boring? This wine falls definitively into the latter camp; it is technically flawless but intellectually static. Honest verdict: Scoring a 15/20 on the Robinson scale, this is an average, competent commercial crowd-pleaser that delivers massive, oak-swathed fruit at the total expense of Pinot Noir's traditional grace.
Vineyard Details:
Sourced from multiple premium AVAs across California to achieve sheer volume and a specific, highly extracted flavor profile. Winemaker Dave Phinney draws coastal minerality from the Sonoma Coast (specifically the Annapolis Vineyard), depth and body from the Russian River Valley (MacMurray Ranch), acidity from the Santa Rita Hills (Sta. Rita Hills AVA), and further weight from Sleepy Hollow in the Santa Lucia Highlands. Soil types across these sites range from coastal Goldridge loam to calcareous marine deposits, though the multi-regional blending completely obscures any site-specific terroir expression. Vine age varies considerably across the contracted sites. At the winery, the grapes were handled with a gentle punchdown fermentation rather than pumpovers to extract rich color without harsh seed tannin, then aged for 10 months in French oak barrels (42 percent new). Annual production sits at approximately 6,650 cases, ensuring wide commercial availability and confirming its status as a scaled production wine rather than a scarce, terroir-driven allocation.
Awards & Accolades
• 91 Points - Robert Parker Wine Advocate (Lisa Perrotti-Brown)
• 90 Points - Wine-Searcher Aggregated Average
• 91 Points - Wine Spectator
• 91 Points - Wine Enthusiast
Learn More
Explore Sophie's guides about this wine:
Fun Facts (0)
No Fun Facts Yet
Be the first to share something interesting about this wine!
Reviews (0)
No Reviews Yet
Be the first to review this wine!