red
Caymus Cabernet Sauvignon
Caymus Vineyards
Vintage & Drinking Window
🍷
Drinking Window
2021-2028. Currently drinking at peak maturity; its low acidity and melted tannins mean it will decline rather than improve with further age.
Perfect time to enjoy!
Vintage Notes
The 2019 growing season in Napa Valley followed a wet winter and delivered a warm, consistent summer with virtually no major heat spikes or harvest-season fires. This untroubled environment allowed the winemaking team to flawlessly execute their signature extended hang-time philosophy. Grapes were left on the vine deep into the autumn, desiccating slightly to achieve immense sugar concentration and drastically lowered natural acidity, resulting in a hyper-ripe, densely packed vintage profile.
AI Confidence: 98%
$90.00 - $110.00 USD
92/100Outstanding
Sophie's Take
Listen to Sophie talk about Caymus Cabernet Sauvignon
0:000:00
Grape Varieties
Red Bordeaux Varieties (approx. 23%, precise blend undisclosed)
Cabernet Sauvignon (approx. 77%)
Style: Evaluating the 2019 Caymus Cabernet Sauvignon through the rigorous BLIC framework reveals a wine engineered for impact rather than internal equilibrium. Balance is entirely weighted toward fruit sweetness and a warm 14.6% ABV, with remarkably low structural acidity providing virtually no tension to cut the weight. The tannins have been completely sanded down into melted velvet, offering a slick texture rather than necessary grip. Intensity is immediately massive, flooding the palate with concentrated boysenberry preserve and sweet mocha. Yet, complexity remains resolutely low; the wine presents a monolithic wall of blue fruit and toasty oak that refuses to unfurl into savory, herbal, or earthy dimensions. The finish shows medium length, though its persistence is driven entirely by confectionary sweetness rather than energetic drive or mineral cut. In terms of typicity, this wine actively rejects classical Napa Cabernet varietal markers like graphite, cedar, and pyrazinic lift, instead forging its own highly commercial, hyper-ripe category. This wine is decidedly not for the classical Bordeaux lover or the terroir-seeking connoisseur who values precision, lift, and savory evolution. Buyers trade off structural tension, vintage transparency, and food-versatility in exchange for absolute, immediate hedonism and a polished, dense texture. Those seeking a true expression of Napa Valley terroir at a similar price point would be much better served by the energetic focus and varietal typicity of Faust or a structurally taut bottling from Corison.
Alcohol: 14.5%
Tasting Notes
Medium-length finish sustained by toasty oak and confectionary sweetness rather than mineral persistence
Pronounced aromatic intensity of baked blackberry preserve, critically lacking aromatic lift
Palate entry is distinctly sweet and viscous, driven entirely by high residual fruit weight
Opaque purple-black core with dense, staining viscosity indicating massive concentration
Heavy overlay of warm vanilla bean and sweet baking spice reflecting prominent oak integration
Noticeably low structural acidity, providing no internal tension or palate-cleansing cut
Professional Ratings
Wine Spectator: 92/100
James Suckling: 93/100
Vinous: 91/100
Serving Recommendations
Temperature: 16-18 C (60-64 F). Serving this wine any warmer will exacerbate the 14.6% ABV and cause the residual sugar to feel cloying.
Decanting: Decant for 60 minutes to integrate the alcohol and allow the dominant vanilla oak to settle. By 120 minutes, the soft structure causes the dark fruit to show fatigue.
Food Pairing:
Dry-aged ribeye steak served medium-rare to anchor the heavy fruit
Peking duck with hoisin sauce (unexpectedly brilliant as the wine acts as a sweet plum sauce equivalent)
Charred beef burgers with caramelized onions to match the sweetness
AVOID: Fresh oysters or delicate ceviche; the wine's residual sugar, massive body, and warm alcohol will obliterate the seafood and turn metallic
Slow-braised short ribs with a dark plum and red wine reduction
Aged crystalline cheddar or gouda to contrast the slick texture
Dark chocolate lava cake (an unexpected pairing that embraces the wine's residual sugar)
Winemaking & Vineyard
Production Notes:
The founding of Caymus in 1972 by Charlie, Lorna, and Chuck Wagner remains one of Napa Valley's foundational commercial myths. Beginning with an initial 240-case run, the estate has grown to define the American luxury grocery-store wine category. Today, Chuck Wagner directs an operation that produces an astounding 141,348 cases of this 2019 Napa Valley Cabernet Sauvignon alone. No wine in America is as culturally contested. It stands as an absolute steakhouse legend that provides drinkers with a predictable, seamless, velvet-draped experience. Yet, it causes fierce polarization among professionals. Wilfred Wong championed the 2019 vintage, stating its layers of persistent and formidable fruit could turn a semi-vegetarian into a carnivore. Conversely, it draws intense backlash from sommeliers and modernist critics who argue it has completely decoupled from traditional winemaking. Controversies continually swirl regarding its noticeable residual sugar and the speculated use of Mega Purple grape concentrate for color enhancement, accusations the winery vehemently denies despite the wine's monolithic opacity. When comparing it to peers like Silver Oak or The Prisoner, Caymus operates in a tier of its own making, entirely outpacing them in pure, unchallenging immediate gratification. However, it fails completely on the fundamental critical test: does it reward attention? Ultimately, no. It is a highly competent product engineered for blunt impact, but it is fundamentally boring in the glass, offering no energetic lift or evolutionary arc over the course of an evening. Because of the massive production volume, it is not a rare collectible and holds virtually no appreciation potential on the secondary market. Honest verdict: This is a commercially brilliant, highly engineered triumph that delivers a 14-point experience for the terroir-focused connoisseur, yet flawlessly executes its actual mission as an unchallenging, sweet-fruited crowd-pleaser.
Vineyard Details:
Fruit is aggregated from growers across eight of Napa Valley's sixteen sub-appellations. Rather than expressing a singular site terroir or specific soil composition, this broad valley-floor and hillside sourcing strategy is deliberately designed to achieve maximum volume while maintaining a standardized, hyper-ripe flavor profile vintage after vintage. Vine ages and specific rootstocks are an undisclosed blend, underscoring the brand's commitment to house style over vineyard transparency.
Awards & Accolades
• Ranked #1 Most Consumed Wine on CellarTracker in 2022
• Wilfred Wong - 93 Points
Learn More
Explore Sophie's guides about this wine:
Fun Facts (0)
No Fun Facts Yet
Be the first to share something interesting about this wine!
Reviews (0)
No Reviews Yet
Be the first to review this wine!